TinyURL.com Blocked by Panera Bread

Could someone help me understand this one?

I can understand Panera choosing to block porn sites, since it could be disturbing for customers to glance over to see a neighboring table watching porn while they're trying to enjoy some bread bowl chowder.

But why is TinyURL.com banned? Why not just block inappropriate sites that people may be trying to access after being redirected from TinyURL.com?

For example, I tried to visit a perfectly legitimate news linked in Twitter via a TinyURL. This was inaccessible to me.

Additionally, I couldn't create TinyURLs for inclusion in emails I was trying to send.

Any theories on why this is on the blocked list?

Listen to this article posted by Ed Kohler on April 15, 2008 8:54 PM | Permalink
More posts about Censorship

                                             

Caribou blocks YouTube and others. The way around it is to use a proxy. Not sure if it will work for TinyURL but it's worth a shot.
Browser-Based Proxies: www.ctunnel.com www.dtunnel.com

This post from Tinotopia three years ago lists sites that we blocked by Panera. My blog, Ian's Messy Desk was blocked as pornography, which it has never been.

It may be a mistake or it may be that the proxy cannot predict the redirect and therefore (to be conservative) it assumes that some tiny url's will be inappropriate.

When I first started using Tiny URL, I used it to send some nasty pics to co-workers as a joke. Blocking it makes sure that doesn't happen.

This is a default block made by SonicWall... I know it well since we use the SonicWall at my office and I have the same TinyURL issues. Other URL translations work. Somewhere along the line somebody at SonicWall must have decided that people would use TinyURL to route around their content filtering and added it to a default block list. It can be fixed if the network admin whitelists TinyURL.com.

Just wanted to clarify that my previous comment is an assumption as I am not the network admin and have not actually made or requested that TinyURL be white listed.

Its official "Panera Bread Hates Rick-Rolling!"

didn't you get the memo?

The message you've received is from a network firewall device from Sonicwall (www.sonicwall.com), which Panera purchased and put in place on their network.

It may be that Sonicwall's Content Filter (which is what they call their website blocking software) has chosen to block TinyURL, or it may be that Panera's network administrator chose to do it.

I'm inclined to believe that Sonicwall did it. You should contact their content filter software team and find out why, and persuade them to unblock it. (It would be even better to persuade Panera to contact Sonicwall, as they are likely a larger customer to whom Sonicwall might pay a little bit of attention.)

Sonicwall is in the U.S. at 888.777.1476.

If you like TinyURL, you might also want to check out http://traceurl.com

TraceURL shortens any URL plus it tracks traffic to the page through the TraceURL shortened web site address, showing where the traffic originated. Count accesses and have the origin of the visitor displayed on a Google Map.

Well looks like being banned and blocked from Panera Bread is the least of Tinyurl.com's worries. For several weeks now I have noticed that none of their redirection links work

In fact if you type their url into your browser (as of May 28th) be it firefox or internet explorer you'll be directed to a page designated "Problem loading page" that notifies you that "The connection was reset"...in any other language that means "too bad buddy!"

So if you happen to be using tinyurl.com to disguise your affiliate links I suggest you seriously reconsider such strategy because those links are obviously not doing you any good!

The most likely cause of the problem is that with in excess of 1 billion hits per month the system just cannot handle the load! this isn't the first time that tinyurl.com has had this problem by the way...assuming this is merely and outage problem and not something more sinister!

Check your hosts file. I had the same problem and it looks like Spybot Search and Destroy added listings for both TinyURL sites so that I couldn't get to them. Removing the entries from my hosts file restored my ability to make TinyURLs. Note that your hosts file may have been set to "Read only" by Spybot, so before you make any changes you'll have to turn that setting off in Windows Explorer.

I'm sitting at Caribou Coffee and same deal..no Tiny and I guess have to take my blog writing and my business elsewhere

Why do coffee bars and mall wi-fi places block so many "normal sites", do they think society is bent on stupidity and explicit pictures?

Check out my blog, feel free to subscribe..

The reason they block your redirected site is due to the inability to filter a the known content of that website. Someone could redirect you to a some sort site that anyone may find offensive. If you can't explicitly block the content based on a url because you don't know where the url will take you it will be banned.

Example: if the host has blocked youtube.com and someone has created a tinyurl.com link to that site, the ability to gain access to a blocked site is back doored. So unless the host had blocked only certain tinyurl.com pages (never going to happen, way too much work) then it is much easier to block any links to that url.

Hope that helps.
vegas

anonymous, I figured that's why they did it, but why wouldn't they just block YouTube when that's requested? Tinyurl is not a proxy.

Some of the commenters here do not seem to understand the nature of TinyURL. It's not a mask or a proxy, it's a redirect. If you use a TinyURL to link to a porn site, the browser will try to load the porn site, and THAT is what goes into the filter. Not a redirect URL.

• Leaving Classmates.com
• The Blind Respond to the Author's Guild Kindle Position
• My Killer iPhone App: Instapaper
• Replacing a MacBook Pro Fan
• Restaurant Web Design Done Right